The Actual Reason Why Castling out of Check is Illegal in Chess

When it comes to the game of chess, casting is a crucial move for the safety of your king. It allows you to move your king to a safer spot while also activating your rook. However, there is one situation where castling is not allowed: when your king is in check.

The rule that prohibits castling out of check raises the question: why is castling out of check illegal? There are actually many explanations for this simple question, but here is the one I believe is the most accurate:

Castling out of check is illegal in chess to prevent players from using it as a means to escape from a check and gain an unfair advantage. This rule maintains the strategic value of the game and ensures its integrity.

I know some of you are already on your way to my contact page to write me a few angry emails about why this is the reason, so please keep reading as I explain why I believe this is the most accurate explanation. After which you can still send me all your angry emails anyway.

How Does Castling Work in Chess?

I know most of those reading are already familiar with casting in chess, but some people don’t, so let’s quickly recap those rules (it’s important for what we will discuss later.

Castling is a move in chess that allows a player to move their king two squares towards a rook on the player’s first rank, and then move the rook to the square over which the king crossed.

Castling is designed to be a superb defensive move and is used to improve the safety of the king by moving it away from the center of the board and placing it behind a row of pawns and a rook.

Castling is subject to certain conditions, such as the absence of any pieces between the king and the rook and the king not being in check.

The 2 Types of Castling in Chess

1. King-side castling:

• The king moves two squares towards the rook on its right side.
• The rook moves to the square over which the king crossed.

2. Queen-side castling:

• The king moves two squares towards the rook on its left side.
• The rook moves to the square over which the king crossed.

It’s important to note that there are certain conditions that must be met in order to castle:

• Neither the king nor the rook involved in castling may have moved previously.
• The squares between the king and the rook involved in castling must be unoccupied.
• The king cannot be in check before or after castling.
• The king cannot move through or to a square that is attacked by an enemy piece during castling.

So, now that we have all reviewed what is casting and why it is important, let’s answer the main question; why can’t you use it to escape a check?

Why Is Castling out of checks illegal?

According to the Rules of FIDE, and I quote directly here:

Castling is prevented temporarily:
[a] if the square on which the king stands, or the square which it must
cross, or the square which it is to occupy, is attacked by one or more of
the opponent’s pieces, or

FIDE Rule Book, Chapter 3.8, section B.

So, whyyyyy?

The reason why castling out of a check is illegal is to prevent players from exploiting the advantage of castling by using it as a means to escape from a check.

The strategic value of the game would be undermined and the player would gain an unfair advantage if castling out of check were allowed.

An Explanation from the Game’s History

In the past, Before the 16th century, castling in chess consisted of two moves. The player had to move the rook first, and then the king could make a unique jump move, which could only be made once per game.

Due to this two-move requirement, it was impossible to castle out of check, as moving the rook alone did not remove the king from the threat of check. It is possible that this historical reason may explain why castling out of checks is still illegal in modern chess.

Another Explanation from the History of Warfare

Chess originated as a game to represent medieval warfare tactics and strategy on the board. In the game, the defensive position of a king in a castle formation mirrors the real-life scenario where kings and lords sought refuge in castles and forts.

However, castling can only be done as a prophylactic move, not as a means to teleport the king from the field of battle in the midst of an attack.

This concept is similar to the defensive strategy used in the movie “The Two Towers” where King Eomer of Rohan chose to take his army and civilians to a defensive position at Helm’s Deep.

If a player could wait until their king is directly under attack to castle, it would diminish the strategic importance of castling as a defensive move.

What happens if you castle while under check?

Since casting out of check is illegal, trying to do so will result in this being counted an illegal move.

Just like with any illegal move, it must be retracted and replaced with a legal move, and the player who made the illegal move may receive a penalty, such as having time added to their opponent’s clock or losing the game entirely depending on whether this is the first or second illegal move they make.

How to Get out of a check?

Since you can’t castle out of check, if you want to castle, you need to handle the check first and then castle.

There are a few ways to get out of check in chess:

1. Move your King: The easiest and most common way to get out of check is to move your King to a square where it is not under attack. This could be to an adjacent square, or to a square further away if there is no immediate threat. Keep in mind that you will lose your right to castle if you move your king, as explained earlier.
2. Block the check: If your opponent is attacking your King with a piece, you can block the attack by placing one of your pieces in between the attacking piece and your King. This will prevent the check and force your opponent to move their piece or capture your blocking piece.
3. Capture the attacking piece: If your opponent is attacking your King with a piece, you can try to capture that piece with one of your own pieces. This will not only stop the check, but also remove the attacking piece from the board.

Did you also know that you don’t have to say “check”? I know, mindblowing for some people. Learn more about the rules about announcing checks in chess here.

Conclusion

In conclusion, castling out of check is not allowed in chess to prevent players from exploiting the advantage of castling by using it as a means to escape from a check. This rule is enforced by chess organizations to maintain the integrity of the game and ensure fairness.

While castling is a valuable move for defensive purposes, it can only be used as a prophylactic move to prepare for potential threats rather than as a means to escape an existing one.

Good luck in your next game, Happy Hunting 😉

If you did find this article helpful, please consider sharing, as it can help this little site grow 🙏